Robert Parkers Wine Advocate (99+ points):
"The 2023 Chateauneuf du Pape from Clos des Papes is exquisite, wafting from the glass with a captivating bouquet of sweet red berries, iris, dark cherries, menthol, blood orange and flowers. Medium- to full-bodied, layered and textured, it’s denser than usual, with a more pronounced structure and a lovely, fleshy core of fruit. Concluding with an ethereal, saline and weightless finish, this is a strong candidate for wine of the vintage—one that should evolve with grace over the coming years to attain a likely perfect score."
The Wine Cellar Insider (99 points):
"The striking bouquet of flowers, mint leaf, kirsch, cherries, and citrus stands out in a crowd. But it is the power, precision, and purity on the palate that let you know this is an exceptional wine. Intense yet relaxed, showy and discreet, this is a solid example of what Chateauneuf does best. This is a remarkable wine that needs to be tasted to understand what makes Chateauneuf great! This is a strong contender for wine of the vintage. Drink from 2027-2045."